Nashville, Tennessee - A man remains in prison. Not because he is guilty. Not because he wants to flee. But because the justice system - in the deepest contradiction of its own principles - can offer him more safety behind bars than in freedom. Kilmar Abrego Garcia, 35, is to remain in pretrial detention. That was the decision of a federal judge on June 30. The reason: they do not trust their own president.
It is a sentence that should sound like a thunderclap in any constitutional democracy. But in Donald Trump's United States, it has become reality. Abrego Garcia was unlawfully deported to El Salvador in March - despite ongoing legal proceedings, despite all legal protections. Only a ruling by the Supreme Court forced the government to bring him back. Now he is back - but not free, rather locked up in a prison in Tennessee. And the strange part: it was his own lawyers who asked that he not be released for now. Not because he is a threat. But because they fear that Trump will deport him again at the next opportunity. An almost unprecedented case in American legal history.
"We cannot rely on any statement made by the Department of Justice," the defense wrote in their motion to the court. The irony of this request, they said, is "lost on no one." In plain terms: the Trump administration is considered so unreliable, so arbitrary, that his defense would rather accept deprivation of liberty than expose their client to a government that ignores its own rulings. Such an approach is almost without precedent in the history of American criminal trials. The incarceration of a person not to enforce criminal law - but to protect him from a presidential overreach. The prison cell as a refuge from a president who places himself above the law. Kilmar Abrego Garcia is charged with human smuggling. His lawyers call the charge "absurd." He is a construction worker, not a smuggler. A political scapegoat, nothing more. Observers see the case as a transparent maneuver: the illegal deportation is to be retroactively justified - with a grave accusation designed to silence all doubt in the public discourse. But the dilemma runs deeper. By keeping him in custody, the state reveals a justice system already torn between law and political opportunism. It is no longer about guilt or innocence, flight risk or charges - it is about the fear that a court order for release might simply be ignored by the executive.
Kilmar Abrego Garcia is more than an isolated case. He is a measure of the public's trust in institutional integrity - and of the scale of political erosion under Donald Trump. In a country that once saw itself as the cradle of the rule of law, a man remains in prison - to be protected from the president. A sentence that no court in the world should ever have to write - and yet it now defines the new America. An America where the independence of the judiciary is no longer a given. An America that no longer trusts itself. And so a man remains behind bars. Not because he is not believed - but because the president is not believed. In truth, it is not Kilmar Abrego Garcia who is on trial - but the American legal system itself.
English 
German 
