Trump's ICE Fiasco: When the State Sacrifices Its Own Rescuers

The email reached FEMA employees late Tuesday night. Management Directed Reassignment Effective August 5, 2025 - a subject line that ended careers and upended lives. Sara Birchenough, a personnel director whose name would normally vanish into the files, sent the ultimatum: seven days to transfer to ICE or lose the job. No discussion, no alternative. The affected employees had been carefully selected. Employees in their probationary period, people with less than one year of service whose labor protections were minimal. They had already been through an absurd odyssey: dismissed at the start of Trump’s second term, reinstated after a court ruling, parked for months on paid leave. Part of those 100,000 federal employees who collected paychecks without being allowed to work - a bureaucratic no man’s land that now came to an end. FEMA had already lost 2,000 employees since Trump took office. The agency meant to protect Americans from natural disasters was being systematically dismantled. At the same time, ICE was swimming in money - 75 billion dollars over four years, a budget that exceeds the military spending of most countries. Yet all those billions could not fix what ICE needed most: people willing to do the job.

The offers grew ever more desperate. Fifty thousand dollar signing bonus. Sixty thousand dollar student loan repayment. The rehiring of retirees. The lifting of age limits. Nothing worked. The agency that was supposed to deport 3,000 people a day could not find anyone who wanted to take on the job. The desperation showed in the ever more generous incentives ICE offered to potential recruits. The agency had offered hiring bonuses of up to 50,000 dollars as part of a program to lure back recently retired employees. It promised student loan forgiveness and generous repayment plans for new recruits. At the same time, another drama was playing out in Florida’s sheriff’s offices. Madison Sheahan, ICE’s deputy director, had sent an email to thousands of local deputies. These officers had been trained through the 287(g) program, a partnership between local authorities and ICE. Sheahan used the email addresses collected for training purposes to poach the deputies directly. The letter spoke of critical times for the nation, of unique responsibility, of urgently needed skills. The reaction was furious. Grady Judd, sheriff of Polk County and normally a Trump supporter, was outraged. His deputies had been trained at the county’s expense, and now ICE was trying to lure them away. “That bites the hand that feeds you,” he said. Other sheriffs were even more blunt: “Like letting the fox into the henhouse,” said the sheriff of Brevard County. “Someone lit the fire at the other end,” said the sheriff of Bradford County.

Jonathan Thompson of the National Sheriffs’ Association called it inappropriate behavior from a partner organization. The sheriffs who had supported ICE as force multipliers felt betrayed. Some demanded public apologies. Judd demanded that Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem “put on her big girl pants and do the right thing.” Some did receive apologies - the sheriff’s office in Forsyth County got one from ICE’s Atlanta office. The timing of these actions could not have been worse. Only weeks earlier, Texas had experienced the most devastating floods in years. More than 120 people died in the floods of the Guadalupe River, including 35 children. FEMA could respond to only a third of the calls for help. The disaster relief hotline was overwhelmed, personnel were lacking everywhere. While people cried out for help, FEMA’s staff was being transferred to ICE.

The numbers tell the story of systematic failure. ICE had been given a budget that defied imagination, yet could not recruit 10,000 new agents. The agency tried everything: recruiting at colleges, in big cities, at job fairs. Dean Cain, a forgotten TV actor, promoted ICE in embarrassing videos. “Help save America,” said the man who once played an illegal alien named Superman. The reality on the ground looked different. ICE agents complained about impossible quotas. They arrested gardeners and janitors, people with no criminal records. Well over two-thirds of those arrested had no criminal past. The agents wondered why they were spending their time chasing working people instead of real criminals. The forced reassignment of FEMA employees was only a symptom of a larger crisis. The Department of Homeland Security said the transfers were temporary, only for 90 days, to help with hiring and screening. But the employees had no experience in immigration enforcement. Many had been trained for specific tasks at FEMA that had nothing to do with ICE’s mission.

The legal questions were complex. Some of the transferred employees were funded through the Disaster Relief Fund, which came with certain restrictions. Federal law allowed them to perform non-disaster-related work for up to 90 days, but only for training purposes. The work at ICE did not fall under that. Trump had promised to abolish FEMA or fundamentally restructure it. “FEMA is slow and cumbersome,” he had said. The states should take more responsibility. But when Texas needed help, it was FEMA that had to respond - with halved staff and bureaucratic hurdles personally imposed by Noem. She insisted on personally approving every contract over 100,000 dollars, which further delayed aid.

Sheriffs in Florida and other states began to reconsider their cooperation with ICE. Some threatened to withdraw from the 287(g) program. The partnership meant to strengthen ICE was collapsing under the pressure of its own greed for personnel. Ron DeSantis, Florida’s governor, publicly criticized ICE’s actions. The sheriffs should defend their agencies, he said, and fight for what was right. History repeats itself with tragic regularity. An administration that claims to want to make America safer systematically weakens the institutions that protect Americans. FEMA is being hollowed out as hurricane season begins. Local partnerships are destroyed to strengthen an agency that does not function despite unlimited resources. The email from Tuesday night was more than a personnel decision. It was an admission of failure. ICE, with its bloated budget and impossible goals, had to plunder other agencies to survive. The deportation machine Trump had promised was eating away at its own foundations.

The FEMA employees faced an impossible choice. The sheriffs felt betrayed. The Texans who died in the floods became collateral damage of a policy that turned priorities upside down. While the administration dreamed of the largest deportation campaign in history, the infrastructure that kept America functioning was falling apart. The promise to protect America turned into its opposite. Instead of security came chaos. Instead of strength came desperation. Instead of order came the desperate attempt to achieve through coercion and threats what could not be achieved through persuasion. In the end, it is the Americans who pay the price - with less disaster protection, shattered local partnerships, and an immigration agency that, despite all its billions, cannot deliver what it promises.

Investigative journalism requires courage, conviction – and your support.

Investigative
Behind every article – especially our in-depth investigative reports – lies significant journalistic effort and financial investment. We do not wish to fund our work through paywalls, but through your voluntary support. How often and in what amount you contribute is entirely up to you – whether as a one-time or recurring contribution.